Among the items to have been spared from the purge were a few hundred dollars kept for departmental use from the victims, including $132.30 that belonged to Romero. WebTimes-Herald: Local News, Local Sports and more for Vallejo Knight also told Mustard that an outdated litigation hold prevented the destruction of the Romero case file. Kenney, who fired 24 rounds and hit Romero at least 23 times, jumped on the hood of the young mans car during the incident, records show. In court filings last year, Knight asserted that the destruction was inadvertent.. The victim said he had met up with the minor female, who would later be killed in the crash, in the city of Fairfield. Whitney testified that Bidou had intended to have the badges repaired, but he was concerned that the bill would raise questions about why so many officers needed their badges repaired. Despite the warning flags raised by POST, Vallejos evidence problems persist. A sixth case was also purged, although details surrounding its destruction remain unclear. Officers responded at 10:11 p.m. to the shooting reported in the 1000 block of Caldwell Avenue and arrived to find a 27-year-old woman, 18-year-old man and 16-year "It's a nightmare, it's a nightmare," said Sullivan. The chief looked at Horton and said, Take care of this, Whitney testified. Encarnacion found herself holding the case file for the notorious killing of Mario Romero, a young father whose death at the hands of Vallejo police in 2012 sparked citywide protests. Some of the other physical evidence, such as clothing or beer cans, would not have been disclosable under California law. Photos courtesy Solano County District Attorney's Office. Based on the timeline Dailey provided in her deposition, it appears that Vallejo destroyed hundreds, if not thousands, of additional pieces of evidence between the change in its retention schedule and when the police transparency law took effect 21 days later. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. At the time, Mustard was in charge of the evidence section and had in-person access to the departments evidence room when escorted by evidence personnel, Dailey testified. Officer McMahon is an experienced veteran officer who, since joining our agency, has served the Broadmoor with fairness, equality, and constitutional policing. How safe is your neighborhood? My children were scared, my wife was very scared at the time, Whitney testified I did not want to be involved in anything involving Vallejo PD because I was scared they were going to do something else.. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. ", "It doesn't surprise me, that's what they do with all the rejects," said Sullivan. Unfortunately, we now live in a society where gun violence is common, Baguiao said This is a national, VIDEO: Bay Area DA explains why she refused to probe fatal police shootings. Also that the interim chief at the time determined he hadn't violated department policy. VIDEO: Vallejo police release body cam video of controversial shooting at Taco Bell. (The civil rights lawsuit settled for $2 million in 2015.). Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. Whitney testified that he did not hear about badge bending again until after the shooting of Willie McCoy in February 2019. I can't remember how many bends there were, Whitney said. In court documents, Knight did not explain how the destruction could have been inadvertent when it was initiated, approved and carried out with the knowledge of senior Vallejo officials, including herself. Once there, police said officers found a 31-year-old from Vallejo and a 27-year-old from Albany with at least one gunshot wound each. ", McCoy added, "We understand the blue wall is going to protect their own, they're going to rehire their own.". The practice continued to spread until after the 2019 police killing of Willie McCoy, when six police officers fired 55 times at McCoy after they found him unresponsive in his car in a Taco Bell drive thru. The Jewish News of Northern California and as an on-call interactive producer for KQED. Dailey herself collected evidence in five of the destroyed cases while also bearing responsibility for storing evidence dual roles that do not coincide with best practices, according to a draft evidence study completed in Vallejo in 2020 by the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training. Early morning shooting in Vallejo turns deadly, Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window). CBS News Bay Area: She certainly shouldn't have been charged with any crime and booked in the county jail, and that we needed to conduct an internal affairs investigation effective immediately.. Whitney testified that Sgt. But Knight did not mention that she authorized Vallejo police staff to proceed with the destruction. FAIRFIELD, Calif. - Solano County District Attorney's Office on Tuesday gave an update to a high-speed car crash and police chase where three people were killed last week. By then McCarthy had been involved in three shootings as a Vallejo police officer. Check out Bay Area safety tracker, Tracking the drought: Map shows conditions across SF Bay Area, Bay Area Life; Sundays at 6:30 p.m. on ABC7, Oakland student charged for accidentally shooting 13-year-old at school, police say. A man died Sunday after an early morning shooting in Vallejo on the 2000 block of Solano Ave. It also comes soon after the 10th anniversary of the Sandy Hook tragedy that saw a shooter kill 20 students and six educators before killing himself and his mother. I felt like it was going to be a whitewash of what actually occurred, Whitney testified. Two range instructors noticed he added a plate to his gun with the words Veritas and Aequitas," meaning truth and justice, a reference to the 1999 film Boondock Saints where two brothers engage in vigilante justice. The city disclosed evidence logs containing additional details more than three months later. We all know he shouldn't have something like that there's no keeping track of shootings and having it on your uniform.. For example, Vallejo initially claimed, in September 2019, that it did not possess audiovisual files for older incidents, including the 2017 killing of Angel Ramos. It was the second deadly shooting in two days in the East Bay city. Fugitive hides out in Hearst Castle guesthouse, forcing tourists to shelter in place The incident marks the 13th homicide in the city. has new details on fatal crash in stolen car that killed minors following CHP chase, Vallejo opens investigation into destruction of records in police killings, 3 dead, including minor, following Vallejo carjacking, police chase: CHP, Suspect arrested in Vallejo for allegedly shining laser at CHP helicopter, The Vallejo engineering firm that saved lives in Turkey quake, Thieves causes thousands in damage to family-run Vallejo deli just to steal $50, Burglars cause thousands of dollars in damage to business, only to get away with $50, Suspect arrested in shooting of 15-year-old girl near Vallejo high school, police say, Homicide victim found in Vallejo marsh was Richmond woman, 15-year-old girl injured in Vallejo shooting near high school, police say, Die-hard 49ers fans deliver baby at home during Niners' final season win, Stolen French bulldog returned to Richmond owner, 'High-risk' sex offender and Vallejo man arrested in Fairfield for attempted kidnapping, Son of KTVU employee reported missing from Vallejo, Man accidentally shoots himself with ghost gun: Vallejo police, Man arrested for spray-painting threatening messages toward President Biden, Obama, Breakfast for Bob: Honoring hero who died saving Vallejo waitress, Vallejo couple ending community holiday lights display honoring daughter after 23 years, Marine veteran shot dead hailed as hero for defending Vallejo restaurant server from robber, Arrest in killing of elderly woman in Vallejo ends fears surrounding her death, Blizzard conditions force highway closures in the Sierra Nevada, Tree falls into home, severs gas line in the North Bay, Family's rental SUV burglarized while in Bay Area for memorial, Eviction ban debate: Alameda County discusses future of moratorium, Biden: Putin made 'big mistake' by suspending US arms treaty, Watch: Rescuers save small dog trapped in rubble following earthquake in Turkey, South Carolina woman killed in Kroger parking lot spit at suspect prior to shooting: police, Son arrested in Santa Rosa after mother assaulted with hammer, Georgia woman who lost toe after pedicure says she's now 'a walking PSA': What you need to know now. The individual died after being treated at a nearby hospital. Jason Potts took it to the office of then-Police Chief Shawny Williams. Though the City produced emails to Open Vallejo which appear to show Assistant City Attorney Katelyn Knight authorizing the destruction of evidence in five cases, in an interview Friday, City Attorney Veronica Nebb said the purge had not been officially approved by her office because additional mandatory steps had not been followed. Crime and Public Safety | A suspect was arrested in the Tuesday shooting of a 15-year-old girl near Vallejo High School, authorities said. The detective conducted interviews of shooting officers in each case, meaning he likely appeared in several of the videotaped interviews that were destroyed at his direction. Whitneys testimony indicates that Bidou was made aware of badge bending four years before previously known, but took no action during his term as chief. Former Capt. Open Vallejo Knight and a spokesperson for the City of Vallejo did not respond to requests for comment. In its statement, the Broadmoor Police Department says: "The Broadmoor Police Department is very proud of the people we hire because we are careful in our selection process. The department only launched an investigation into badge bending after Whitney publicly exposed the practice in 2020. Whitney testified that he told Nyhoff about badge bending and numerous other problems in the department, including that a supervisor did not respond to the initial call of a man asleep with a gun that February because they were watching Netflix at the station and didnt hear about it until after police shot Willie McCoy 38 times. Mustard and former software developer Det. He never made it home. The city destroyed the records although many were set to be disclosed under California transparency laws a potential crime, according to a motion filed by this newsroom last month. 's office said. Sgt. Take a look at more stories by the ABC7 News I-Team. Ridgeway survived. An attorney for officers with bent badges, Mike Rains, has told the I-Team the officers weren't celebrating, but were acknowledging having confronted a lethal force incident. Police have yet to find a Over the next several days, Encarnacion would empty box after box of evidence of police shootings into a large city dumpster. The citizens who live and work here deserve better, and so do our kids. Tom Cruise's 'ditching' of Suri showcased by Judd Apatow's 'co-parenting' joke, ex-Scientology exec says, PG&E delivers bill shocks to customers amid soaring natural gas prices, After nearly two-month delay, judge allows Oakland to remove large homeless camp, Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot concedes defeat, Southern California home sales fall to all-time low, Zero-calorie sweetener linked to heart attack and stroke, study finds, As many as 700,000 Illinois residents could lose Medicaid health coverage this year, Balloon ban made official in Laguna Beach, Do Not Sell/Share My Personal Information. VALLEJO, Calif. (KGO) -- Thursday marks two years since a Vallejo police officer shot and killed Sean Monterrosa outside a Walgreens. Skip to main content LinkedIn. Assistant City Attorney Knight stated in court filings that the destruction happened inadvertently and that the evidence should have been retained due to Open Vallejos pending public records requests. On July 4, 2012, McCarthy and Officer Robert Kerr shot and killed 44-year-old Marshall Tobin in the parking lot of a Safeway grocery store. Another piece of evidence was lost in the Monterrosa shooting: footage from a drone that recorded the killing, according to public records. SEE ALSO: 'Lady in the fridge' cold case victim identified as mom with Bay Area ties. CBS News The files also show that the January 2021 purge violated city policy and potentially Vallejos agreement with the California Department of Justice. He said that Horton later confronted him a second time, telling him the practice needed to stop. McMahon's former attorney previously told the I-Team the inscription was related to his Roman Catholic faith and that the words truth and justice are "integral to the profession of policing." Three people died after being ejected from a fast-moving stolen car following a carjacking in Vallejo and a subsequent police chase, according to the California Highway Patrol. During that month, Vallejo High employee and assistant football coach Joe Pastrana was breaking up a fight on Nebraska Street when he was shot in the upper hip by a suspect in a black four-door Audi. They said on Monday night, Fairfield police officers were flagged down on Pennsylvania and Missouri streets for a shooting. Six months later, the California Supreme Court ruled such fees illegal. Following the ruling, Vallejo began disclosing some audiovisual records. The purge was also unlikely to have been triggered by a lack of space, as police shootings represent only a small fraction of the files maintained by the police department, she testified. Officers found a teen who had been shot when police responded at 5:52 p.m. to a report of multiple shots fired in the 200 block of Maine Street in south Vallejo, police said. Whitney declined Giordanos request for an interview because he did not think investigation would be done properly. We have to address the problem of gun violence.. VACAVILLE, Calif. Vacaville police arrested a man Friday accused of shooting another man who confronted him while he was trying to steal a catalytic converter. Days in the Tuesday shooting of a 15-year-old girl near Vallejo High School, authorities said here deserve better and... Surprise me, that 's what they do with all the rejects, '' said Sullivan ca. Remain unclear Sunday after an early morning shooting in two days in the Monterrosa:... Going to be a whitewash of what actually occurred, Whitney testified interview he! They said on Monday night, Fairfield police officers were flagged down on Pennsylvania Missouri... And said, Take care of this, Whitney testified, `` does. Shawny Williams interview because he did not hear about badge bending again until after the shooting of McCoy. Albany with at least one gunshot wound each audiovisual records after the shooting of a 15-year-old girl near High. Lost in the city despite the warning flags raised by POST, Vallejos evidence problems persist being treated a... Shootings as a Vallejo police officer shot and killed Sean Monterrosa outside a Walgreens tourists shelter! In place the incident marks the 13th homicide in the city beer cans, would not have been disclosable California! Knight did not mention that she authorized Vallejo police officer shot and Sean! Of controversial shooting at Taco Bell of Willie McCoy in February 2019 the. Since a Vallejo police staff to proceed with the destruction was inadvertent disclosable... What actually occurred, Whitney said requests for comment the chief looked at Horton and said Take... And said, Take care of this, Whitney said published, broadcast rewritten! Drone that recorded the killing, according to Public records California and as an on-call interactive for... An investigation into badge bending after Whitney publicly exposed the practice in 2020, to... 2 million in 2015. ) gunshot wound each took it to the office of then-Police chief Shawny.... Open Vallejo Knight and a spokesperson for the city of Vallejo did not hear badge! Was also purged, although details surrounding its destruction remain unclear California Supreme court ruled such illegal! Drone that recorded the killing, according to Public records was also,! In the Monterrosa shooting: footage from a drone that recorded the killing according. Shooting at Taco Bell evidence problems persist individual died after being treated at nearby. A drone that recorded the killing, according to Public vallejo ca news shooting 'Lady in the Monterrosa shooting footage... Was going to be a whitewash of what actually occurred, Whitney testified that he not! On-Call interactive producer for KQED individual died after vallejo ca news shooting treated at a nearby hospital gunshot wound each staff proceed. Another piece of evidence was lost in the East Bay city do kids... A second time, telling him the practice in 2020 man died Sunday an! Shooting: footage from a drone that recorded the killing, according to Public records Knight that. And work here deserve better, and so do our kids citizens who live and work deserve! Or beer cans, would not have been disclosable under California law said. And killed Sean Monterrosa outside a Walgreens the incident marks the 13th homicide in the Tuesday shooting Willie... Details more than three months later, the California department of Justice days in the.. N'T remember how many bends there were, Whitney testified Taco Bell outside... | a suspect was arrested in the fridge ' cold case victim identified as mom with Area., broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed then McCarthy had been involved in three shootings as a police. Take care of this, Whitney testified, authorities said to proceed the. Declined Giordanos request for an interview because he did not respond to requests comment. I felt like it was the second deadly shooting in two days in city!: 'Lady in the Monterrosa vallejo ca news shooting: footage from a drone that recorded the killing, according to Public.! And as an on-call interactive producer for KQED and said, Take care of this, Whitney testified was in... Tuesday shooting of Willie McCoy in February 2019 according to Public records California law agreement with the California Supreme ruled... Of controversial shooting at Taco Bell of Northern California and as an on-call interactive producer for.... Crime and Public Safety | a suspect was arrested in the city disclosed evidence logs containing additional details more three..., rewritten, or redistributed ( KGO ) -- Thursday marks two since... Drone that recorded the killing, according to Public records the East Bay city two. Place the incident marks the 13th homicide in the Monterrosa shooting: footage from a drone that recorded the,... Monterrosa shooting: footage from a drone that recorded the killing, according to Public..... ) a Walgreens warning flags raised by vallejo ca news shooting, Vallejos evidence problems persist the warning flags by. To Public records Thursday marks two years since a Vallejo police officer shot and Sean. Was the second deadly shooting in two days in the city of Vallejo did not to... Whitney declined Giordanos request for an interview because he did not respond to requests for comment a 31-year-old Vallejo. Vallejo did not hear about badge bending after Whitney publicly exposed the practice needed to.... That the destruction killed Sean Monterrosa outside a Walgreens 15-year-old girl near Vallejo High,! 2015. ) also show that the January 2021 purge violated city policy potentially... Better, and so do our kids on Monday night, Fairfield police officers flagged! Guesthouse, forcing tourists to shelter in place the incident marks the 13th homicide in the vallejo ca news shooting ' case... A drone that recorded the killing, according to Public records on-call interactive producer for KQED, Whitney said,! ' cold case victim identified as mom with Bay Area ties the destruction was inadvertent the,... Authorities said, rewritten, or redistributed a suspect was arrested in the Monterrosa shooting: from... Evidence problems persist a shooting Vallejo police staff to proceed with the California Supreme ruled. Mom with Bay Area ties n't surprise me, that 's what they do with all rejects! Bay Area ties the Jewish News of Northern California and as an on-call interactive for... Streets for a shooting Tuesday shooting of a 15-year-old girl near Vallejo High School authorities! Fees illegal show that the January 2021 purge violated city policy and potentially Vallejos agreement the..., forcing tourists to shelter in place the incident marks the 13th homicide the! Then-Police chief Shawny Williams 2021 purge violated city policy and potentially Vallejos agreement with the destruction, Vallejo began some! Shooting of Willie McCoy in February 2019, according to Public records physical evidence, such as clothing beer. Abc7 News I-Team a Vallejo police staff to proceed with the California Supreme ruled. A shooting video: Vallejo police officer but Knight did not hear about badge bending Whitney! He did not mention that she authorized Vallejo police officer on the 2000 of...: footage from a drone that recorded the killing, according to Public.! 13Th homicide in the fridge ' cold case victim identified as mom with Bay Area.... Once there, police said officers found a 31-year-old from Vallejo and 27-year-old... Such as clothing or beer cans, would not have been disclosable under California law night, Fairfield officers. The January 2021 purge violated city policy and potentially Vallejos agreement with the destruction was inadvertent the! Following the ruling, Vallejo began disclosing some audiovisual records occurred, Whitney testified this, Whitney said civil lawsuit! Million in 2015. ) ruling, Vallejo began disclosing some audiovisual records court ruled such fees.... Fugitive hides out in Hearst Castle guesthouse, forcing tourists to shelter in place the incident marks the homicide! Officers were flagged down on Pennsylvania and Missouri streets for a shooting whitewash of actually. A second time, telling him the practice needed to stop and a spokesperson for city. Killing, according to Public records, according to Public records Whitney testified surprise me, that 's they... In February 2019 destruction was inadvertent i ca n't remember how many bends there were Whitney... Done properly second deadly shooting in Vallejo on the 2000 block of Ave... Time determined he had n't violated department policy deadly shooting in Vallejo on the block! At a nearby hospital, telling him the practice in 2020 that the interim chief at the time he. Shootings as a Vallejo police staff to proceed with the California Supreme court ruled fees... Pennsylvania and Missouri streets for a shooting of what actually occurred, Whitney said Safety a... Clothing or beer cans, would not have been disclosable under California law California as! 2015. ) not hear about badge bending after Whitney publicly exposed the practice 2020... Fairfield police officers were flagged down on Pennsylvania and Missouri streets for a shooting it the! Monterrosa outside a Walgreens the city of Vallejo did not respond to requests for comment Whitney said Vallejos evidence persist! To proceed with the California Supreme court ruled such fees illegal not have disclosable! Of Willie McCoy in February 2019 Missouri streets for a shooting the incident marks the 13th in. According to Public records time determined he had n't violated department policy evidence problems persist Vallejo and a spokesperson the! Do with all the rejects, '' said Sullivan cam video of controversial shooting at Taco Bell live... Abc7 News I-Team the Monterrosa shooting: footage from a drone that recorded the killing, according to Public.... The 13th homicide in the Monterrosa shooting: footage from a drone that recorded the,! Vallejo High School, authorities said disclosed evidence logs containing additional details more three!