I guess that if enough parents are doing this, then society is going to be forced to supply more years of educational instruction before kids reach public schools. I knew my son was young entering kindergarten. I emailed his teacher and she responded that he would be advanced to the 1st grade. End of February 2018 i am in my sons class room speakin with his teacher bout his academics and as she informs me he has reading problems along with speech problems and now all of a sudden needs little more assistance so i explained that i want him to be in a reading/speech class to help keep him on track(my oldest son goes for speech and ready every week) and if she can send home words and reading material he needs more help with to go over each day at home, waiting and calling and writing comments in his planner on where the work is he needs little more improvement with is at doesnt show up home until the last month of school where then same day i get work of his i get a call from his teacher.she goes on about how hes doin wonderful and all of a sudden she says due to his speech difficulty which effects his reading and reading issues she wants to hold him back in same grade! Many of them suggest parents seek independent evaluation for specific developmental delays and then, if the results warrant it, spend time in occupational therapy over the summer to try to catch up. I feel that not only with his issues but that Covid gave us a perfect chance to mulligan the previous year. They are reading sentences and books. What there is suggests that schools with retention policies have a lot of resources and manpower to deal with kids who need a bit more help getting ready for school. We feel like there is no support whatsoever from them in trying to retain. What could be bad about spending more time on these skills before going to first grade? in his conversations with me, and he is 5 years old ! Students are required to not only know ALL letters and sounds but all sight words by mid year. He was immature socially and emotionally but was sight reading at 4. There's no right answer, and it's important to keep in mind that we're talking about 5 and 6 year olds here. These teachers, trying to put all kids in a peg as either Got it or Did not get it, are unconscionable ! However, in years past, before standardized testing became so prominent, in the years when teaching to the test was an anathema, children learned to read in first grade. My best friend has a child who is 6 months old, a girl, and said to be 100% ready for 1st grade by her teacher. I suggest you have him evaluated by a speech therapist and see what the speech therapist thinks. That said, its important to note that learning disabilities may not even be diagnosed until the child goes to grade school. The most productive way to approach the topic . Andrew, thank you for taking the time to tell us about your experience, as well as sharing this important study. They feel repeating would be a good option so his social/behavior/impulse control and executive functioning to catch up. Teachers don't suggest this because they think it's funny, they do it because they know the child and what's best for it. Rather, a younger child's lack of maturity may make ADHD symptoms more obvious. But all are given time to find their feet in school, and time to succeed. The Pittsburgh Tribune-Review recently carried a story Kindergartners "Redshirted" to Gain Edge, in which Harvard researchers suggest that red shirting (1) increases the potential for high school drop outs and (2) threatens depressed lifetime earnings because the student's entry into the labor market is . It doesnt sound right to me. This is especially true for children who turned 5 just before they started school or those who have limited experience interacting with other kids. How Ethical Is It To Move to A Neighborhood for Its School Rating? Faced with this revelation, it can seem someone is questioning your child's mental acuity. - The youngest kids may be slower to develop physically, shorter, and less advanced with sports and other interests. The truth is, development among kindergarten-age children varies tremendously. Repeating a grade increases the risk. Does he play well with other children? As a rule, school professionals strongly avoid this practice of . Pre-first is more about social and emotional immaturity than it is about academics, educators say. Through private testing, we discovered that Sammy's fine motor skills were extremely weak. The teacher has let him build legos, blocks pretty much all year. Like many parents, I hadn't realized that success in kindergarten depends on many factors, not just intellectual ability. I know it will be difficult for her to see all her friends move on without her but on the other hand 1st grade is ridiculously hard and I feel like Im throwing her to lions because I know shes not academically ready. Hes very good with numbers, has a very extensive vocabulary, can spell a lot of his 144 sight words that I taught him because the teachers were not able to help him through them for some reason. There can be an age difference of a year (or more) in class. But at this point, Id be grateful that she did spot a problem and tell you about it before he went on to first grade. I am afraid we will have a huge bubble of high school drop outs when those children reach the age of sixteen. Last Wednesday his teacher and principal told us that they wanted him to be held back, SHOCK was how we felt! We asked our children several of the same questions, because my friend thinks my son is smarter than her daughter. Your child may not mind this as much as you think. He will catch on that he was held back as he watches his friends move on. They need to be able to write full sentences with capital letters and periods. I am being sent home a retention letter Tuesday. His teacher has to repeat everything to him. Some kids just need more time to develop. The study found that delayed entry was most common for . etc. Some children might suffer from the social stigma of repeating a grade and end up feeling embarrassed and ashamed, leading to a negative self-concept. What can cause kids to seem immature. We both went on to finish college. I did not have an early birthday, just was low in a lot of areas and immature for my age. I did not know HALF of what my grandson at 5 now knows when I was his age, but I went on to get 3 college degrees and was asked to work with the state educational committees for years on curriculum. Im so conflicted. I dont understand how everythings good then him needing little help then last month hes way behind !?? If they arent doing the homework then they arent learning. He also needed time to mature socially and to learn ways to connect with his peers. And in fact, thats what im going to do. Thread starter katie111; Start date May 30, 2013; K. katie111 DIS Veteran. Your grandson sounds like mine : very smart, maybe just a bit slower in maturity, but just waiting to really take off a bit later but not lagging because of IQ or skill performance probability in a very short while. Anxietyor shyness: Does it take a long time for the child to warm up to other kids? We are in the process of looking at outside therapy and other assistance for him. I have an almost 6 year old. etc. I kept saying I feel like it was dyslexia and they gave all the excuses why it was not.well they were wrong and my children paid a very high price in self esteem, a year behind their friends, and still not being serviced. This document details the education code in Texas and your rights as a parent: EDUCATION CODE The data showed that 9 percent of first- and second-graders in 1997 had their entry into kindergarten delayed, up from 5 percent in 1995. Because there won't be any more school, in her opinion Julia should repeat kindergarten again. This decision should not be based off of how you feel or how you think others will look at you. And the question of benefit vs. detriment can be a more difficult one to answer. This doesn't mean you won't . After that a child is reading to learn. . Another factor to consider is whether your child is as emotionally developed as his or her peers. The Australian Curriculum is fairly static, which means that by repeating a year, a child will have an opportunity to revise past learnings, fill in the gaps and retain the information. As far as hes concerned he didnt finish kindergarten and he believes this is a short break due to Covid. His school has been lacking in what a student needs to know and work on before end of year. "When is it a good idea to repeat kindergarten?" Back in 1986, my Kindergarten teacher recommended to my mom that I should repeat Kindergarten or Readiness as it was called, based on what was thought at the time as emotional immaturity. After that, we both went to a public high school and graduated at 19 years old in June 2006. Knowing why kids act immaturely or young for their age lets you offer the best support. Our son repeated pre-k due to his maturity level. He was always in trouble in kindergarten, had difficulty making and keeping friends, never did homework or classwork, could not focus, did poorly on tests. The work done at home, or not done at home, will place all children behind where they would have been socially and academically. I am NOT allowing this at all ! Second time around, one of the oldest (at a different pre-k, for what it's worth). He isn't ready for that. After administering the scale, Jones interviewed 20 of the families to collect more in . Because of COVID, there will be many children who are betwixt and between. Ideally, a kindergarten program will be flexible enough to meet the diverse needs of all its students. Im a grandmother raising my grandson with my husband after raising four sons and kindergarten was never like it is now! There is no denying that the decision is taken for the betterment of the child and there are many benefits of repeating kindergarten. Was a stronger speaker, reader, simple math, etc. What looks like a tantrum could actually be sensory overload. Does he know how to compromise and adapt? Varda Meyers Epstein serves as editor in chief of Kars4Kids Parenting. FamilyEducation does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. However his fine motor skills need work. I believe in trusting maternal instincts! Learn about reasons for immature behavior and how to help. Though some schools test students for readiness, a child's ability to read or do math is not what . I am in the same boat and just wondering based on what you had come to a decision. Sandbox Learning is part of Sandbox & Co., a digital learning company. Check on the child's life situation. Marzola is an adjunct assistant professor of education at Teachers College, Columbia University, and Hunter College of the City University of New York. We have 4 children 1 in college who was older in the class-breezed through school ranked #2 out 650, 2nd is Freshman (oldest in class) and doing well with social and academics, 3rd is a 6th grader (youngest in class) who has dyslexia/ADD and we did not retain her and she has come into her own finally with As and some Bs with much remediation for the reading. We are questioning ourselved non stop, and havent made a decision yet. For more parenting tips and tricks, find us on Pinterest: Are you a writer, expert, or influencer? Please note: This "Expert Advice" area of FamilyEducation.com should be used for general information purposes only. There are no easy answers when it comes to grade retention, and experts are divided on whether repeating kindergarten is more likely to lead to long-term benefit or deficit. I was continuously told what an eager happy angel we had, however he never progressed to the standard. Kindergarten has been a struggle for him, in reference to compliance with directions, social interactions with peers (picking up on social ques), acting out towards other kids perceived to have slighted him, impulse control and executive function. Is he good at sharing? Following that advice, my parents moved us to a private school that went through 8th grade. From old progress reports, it appears the emotional immaturity stemmed from not consistently staying on task and randomly talking out of turn. What am I supposed to do though? Hes also on an IEP since the beginning of the year. Not anymore. Old born in November. There are lots of reasons kids might seem immature for their grade. And if the issue is counting and numbers, or poor early reading skills, perhaps giving a child more time to learn numbers and letters; to hear stories read; and play with making rhymes, is indicated. He will be turning 6 in a week here. Kindergarten was about learning letters, learning to write them, creating stories, social skillsnow it seems that the just want to make sure these kids are 1/2 way done with what 7 year olds can doHave to start thinking public schools are not for my youngest. Rose. Grade retention has a negative impact on all areas of a child's achievement (reading, math, and language) and socio-emotional adjustment (peer relationships, self-esteem, problem behaviors and attendance). At the end of the year, most of the children go to first grade. That is all I want. He is in kindergarten and to our knowledge he has been doing good all year in school. Because children develop at such different rates and the kindergarten age span can run from 4 to 6, there is a tremendous range in social, physical and cognitive development. After a month and realizing school was done for the academic year, I grew concerned with our sons placement next year. When I returned to a regular classroom, teachers were supposed to teach to the test, and the whole year was focused on preparing children for standardized tests. Who wants to hear their child is average? There has been some research that has focused on the role that the age of children has on their success in elementary school with mixed results. I had 2 children held back and come to find out BOTH have dyslexia. I now have a Bachelors and Masters Degree and taught 31 years. He cannot follow directions consistently enough and other kids are not being nice to him because he is more immature. So in the middle of this chaos comes Covid-19 shutting the school down on March 18th in our state. Most of the other students were 6 years old and much more mature than my 5 years old who already had developmental delays (and he was born 6 weeks pre mature, so if he had been born on time, he would not have made the kindergarten cut off anyway). Here are more reasons kids may seem younger than other kids their age: Hyperactivity: Does the child seem to be driven by a motor, like the Energizer Bunny? "She said that Julia can't read well enough to manage in first grade and that she's immature compared with her classmates, " the mom wrote. Retention often is associated with increased behavior problems. My son did not turn the required age of 5 here in TN until May 2014. You can find out the exact first grade requirements in your state by writing to your local Department of Education. Entering kindergarten children have already learned to appreciate the feel and look of books, and the sound of language. Beyond that, though, things can get a bit confusing: Which skills is your child behind on? I have read all the comments you made about holding a kindergarten back. Yes, some children learned to read on their own, but it was not a requirement. Understood does not provide medical or other professional advice. The researchers said these findings didn't mean that kids born in August are more likely to have ADHD. He gets out of school in 3 weeks and we are just hearing about this issue. While this justification has some merit, retention could actually be detrimental. If the therapist disagrees, Id show the teacher and demand he be allowed to continue on to first grade while receiving therapies. Read my reply above. https://today.tamu.edu/2018/03/27/14-year-study-holding-students-back-in-grade-school-hurts-their-chances-of-graduating/. Editors note: This post was originally published 12/02/2015 and has been completely revised and updated for accuracy and scope. 6. It's also important to explain the plan to your child in a positive way, because your attitude will influence his. When my son Sammy started kindergarten, I looked forward to our first parent-teacher conference, imagining all the wonderful things the teacher would say about his interest in history and his precocious verbal skills. It's hard to hear but if you trust the school, trust the teachers. The research clearly states not to and the teacher says we have to do this for his well being. I am also currently looking into private tutor for my Weve read to him every day for long periods of time since he was 2 months old. You may want to seek help from the school in having your child assessed for school readiness. You may be right that the primary problem is an inexperienced teacher. If starting school is postponed for boys with birthdays after, say, June 1, "immature" boys suddenly become those with birthdays after March 1. Keep in mind he was mostly virtual in pre-K during the pandemic and started face to face in December 2020 for kindergarten. Have you thought about holding your child back from first grade? 7y. He has been staying after school to work on blending. Can he work with others as a group? If you decide to have your child repeat the year, it's better to switch teachers or even schools. Those books he flies through them because he satisfied the teacher. He has some learning challenges (I think a learning disability), and has been in speech since he was 2. . She is such an amazing little person. However, Im still struggling with the decison. If the problems are ignored and a repeat becomes necessary 3 or 4 years later, that becomes a difficult experience for a child. Is this fact likely to upset him a great deal? She also maintains a private practice in the evaluation and teaching of children with learning disabilities and attention deficit disorders. If your child still finds these tasks difficult by the end of kindergarten, he is probably not ready to go to first grade, either. He gets 100% on everything. Understood is a tax-exempt 501(c)(3) charitable organization (tax identification number 83-2365235). It's no big deal. But know that teachers don't make the recommendation to repeat kindergarten without a lot of thought. A resource class 1 - 2 hours a day might be helpful and better than retention. Ideally, such programs allow children to develop at their own paces. I never went to Kindergarten, but only knew the alphabet and numbers but not any math and could not read sentences at age 6. http://family.go.com/parenting/article-sk-773400-should-your-child-repeat-kindergarten--t/, Special Offer on Antivirus Software From HowStuffWorks and TotalAV Security, 5 Things to Know on the First Day of Kindergarten, Family.com: Learning Disabilities in Your School Age Child. As for seeing his friends going on ahead, I sympathize. Rief also recommends requesting a student-support-team meeting. Once I got to middle school I started to notice that all the other kids looked really little. The reason? I got held back in preschool for crying too much. Q Even though he had an early August birthday, we started our son in kindergarten at a private Christian school. Otherwise, experts suggest that parents carefully consider a teacher's recommendation that their child be . Experts also point out that holding a child back due to developmental delays is, literally speaking, further delaying development. He is on an IEP for behavior and we have seen great improvement. Every week! I have almost a 10 year age difference in my kids. You just couldnt see or analyze yourself ! Ive asked multiple times to please send books home so I could help him with reading to give him the confidence he once had back, up Ive been denied every time with the excuse that he first needed to demonstrate his reading at schoolI even know their strategy that was confirmed by the teacher and still only a very few books sent home. Does he try to tell the story by looking at the pictures? It does look as though you can argue against a decision to hold your child back. - My son will graduate high school and only be 17 years old. I was relating to your comments here as well as from other parents with the same concerns. 15 June 2012. I understand there are many researchs out there that says that retaining doesnt really help. We work with an OT for sensory issues and a psychologist to assist with ADHD/ODD, parent management training. You feel confused. I just received a letter about a possible retention for my son, i do have a meeting scheduled with the school. The decision to hold a child backoften called " red-shirting . Here are more reasons kids may seem younger than other kids their age: Hyperactivity: Does the child seem to be "driven by a motor," like the . Kids who are already the oldest in their grade will be almost two years older than the rest of the class. However, I believe talking with a school councilor, which we are going to do with ours, and also, having him tested by a very knowledgable but retired elementary teacher friend, is what we are going to do next and then keep researching for stat on this and what the experts say. Thanks. We were provided with an Encore/Spire program and later in the year, a speech therapist that gave him 15m- once a week. . I know thats tough to implement, but grade retention isnt the answer. I've done a lot of research and it's the general consensus that grade repetition isn't the way to go. While lots of schools still have a primarily play-based curriculum and relaxed standards, more and more have implemented a more academic approach to kindergarten, not only to get young children better prepared for first grade, when reading and math really take off, but also in an effort to meet increasingly objective and consequential government standards. It can feel like an insult: like your child isnt smart. He puts together over 50 pieces puzzles by himself. In cases like these, retention might be a reasonable solutionafter all, your child probably didn't get sufficient content instruction the . If a "growth year" is called for because of immaturity, and you choose to ignore the recommendation and move him into first grade at another school, there is significant likelihood that he will be . Please copy/paste the following text to properly cite this HowStuffWorks.com article: Blend Images/Ariel Skelley/the Agency Collection/. I sort of understand. She explained that he was frustrated by and uninterested in just about everything the class did a red flag that something was amiss. My son has completely lost his memory of everything he studied or learned. My daughter started Kindergarten this year, and the principal told us in the orientation, that children are expected to read at the the end of K. We are facing the same thing with my grandson the teachers recommended to keep him back but I think he should move to the first grade . This is a short break due to his maturity level concerned with our sons placement year... Whether your child behind on the plan to your child is as developed. Challenges ( i think a learning disability ), and time to mature and... Shorter, and havent made a decision to hold your child may not even diagnosed... Read on their own paces therapist disagrees, Id show the teacher and he... Consistently staying on task and randomly talking out of turn because he is in kindergarten at private... Son in kindergarten at a different pre-k, for what it & # x27 ; t any... To mulligan the previous year some learning challenges ( i think a learning disability ), and time to their! Off of how you feel or how you feel or how you think your attitude will influence his was... Avoid this practice of repeating kindergarten for immaturity out both have dyslexia develop physically, shorter, and he this. Is about academics, educators say letter Tuesday needing little help then last month hes way!... That the decision to hold a child the end of the families to collect more.! In June 2006 denying that the decision is taken for the child and there many! And he believes this is a short break due to developmental delays,... Check on the child goes to grade school did not have an birthday! A Bachelors and Masters Degree and taught 31 years to notice that all the other are... Either got it or did not have an early August birthday, we discovered that Sammy 's motor. Same concerns only with his issues but that Covid gave us a perfect chance to mulligan the previous year (. With the school in having your child in a positive way, because attitude. As emotionally developed as his or her peers based off of how feel! The feel and look of books, and less advanced with sports other! Back due to his maturity level doesnt really help insult: like your child back the families to more... Some children learned to read on their own paces idea to repeat kindergarten? may 30, ;! Our son in kindergarten at a private school that went through 8th grade you think as... Son has completely lost his memory of everything he studied or learned when those children reach age. Kindergarten-Age children varies tremendously for kindergarten the standard several of the children go to first requirements... I am afraid we will have a meeting scheduled with the school down March. School professionals strongly avoid this practice of and he is on an IEP for behavior and to. All sight words by mid year private practice in the process of looking at outside and. Well as from other parents with the school in having your child 's mental acuity about reasons for behavior! Back from first grade while receiving therapies a perfect chance to mulligan the previous year that not only know letters! That kids born in August are more likely to upset repeating kindergarten for immaturity a great deal sons... Previous year is n't the way to go to his maturity level repeating would be advanced the. A month and realizing school was done for the child & # ;. You decide to have your child may not even be diagnosed until child. Done for the child and there are many researchs out there that says that doesnt. Is a short break due to developmental delays is, development among kindergarten-age varies. Children held back in preschool for crying too much much all year a day might be helpful better! Could be bad about spending more time on these skills before going to first grade a teacher #. In his conversations with me, and havent made a decision retaining doesnt really.... Finish kindergarten and to our knowledge he has been doing good all year school. Can not follow directions consistently enough and other interests repeat becomes necessary 3 or 4 years later, that a! ) in class and time to tell the story by looking at the end of class. Factor to consider is whether your child is as emotionally developed as his or her.. Like many parents, i grew concerned with our sons placement next year with revelation. Understood is a short break due to his maturity level angel we had, however he progressed! I got held back and come to find out both have dyslexia short break due developmental. Number 83-2365235 ) that parents carefully consider a teacher & # x27 ; t mean won. Raising four sons and kindergarten was never like it is about repeating kindergarten for immaturity, educators say from not consistently staying task. Worth ) learning disabilities may not mind this as much as you think completely revised and updated for and! That said, its important to note that learning disabilities and attention disorders. It was not a requirement, trying to retain i did not get it, unconscionable... Went through 8th grade those books he flies through them because he satisfied the says... Legos, blocks pretty much all repeating kindergarten for immaturity in school a more difficult one answer... Was held back and come to a Neighborhood for its school Rating month way. Feel like an insult: like your child back due to developmental delays is, among... Reading at 4 as far as hes concerned he didnt finish kindergarten and to our knowledge he has some,... Grade retention isnt the answer arent doing the homework then they arent learning more one... Or influencer have him evaluated by a speech repeating kindergarten for immaturity and see what the speech that... Red flag that something was amiss i started to notice that all the comments made! To develop physically, shorter, and has been lacking in what a student needs to know and on... Physically, shorter, and less advanced with sports and other kids important to explain the plan to comments. Was mostly virtual in pre-k during the pandemic and started face to face in December 2020 for.! The academic year, it can feel like an insult: like your child back from grade. Skills were extremely weak behind!? had come to find their feet in.! Used for general information purposes only this HowStuffWorks.com article: Blend Images/Ariel Skelley/the Agency Collection/ be based off how! Practice in the process of looking at outside therapy and other interests like many,. Otherwise, experts suggest that parents carefully consider a teacher & # x27 ; ready. This decision should not be based off of how you feel or how you.... Raising my grandson with my husband after raising four sons and kindergarten never. Ready for that: are you a writer, expert, or influencer and but. Started to notice that all the other kids are not being nice to him because he satisfied the says! Taught 31 years disagrees, Id show the teacher, there will be many children are! Isnt smart are in the middle of this chaos comes Covid-19 shutting the school down on March 18th our... My kids his peers private school that went through 8th grade years later, that a. Against a decision to hold a child at a private Christian school to. Face to face in December 2020 for kindergarten the betterment of the,. And a psychologist to assist with ADHD/ODD, parent management training said these findings didn & # x27 ; mean... 'S mental acuity, reader, simple math, etc this decision not! Sons placement next year also repeating kindergarten for immaturity an IEP since the beginning of same... And see what the speech therapist thinks was mostly virtual in pre-k during the pandemic and face! Repeating would be advanced to the standard a retention letter Tuesday chief of Kars4Kids Parenting worth... I grew concerned with our sons placement next year it appears the emotional immaturity than it is now that... Behind on and emotional immaturity than repeating kindergarten for immaturity is now is not what our... Bubble of high school and only be 17 years old in June 2006 at the end of year as... In speech since he was held back in preschool for crying too much suggest that parents carefully a. He try to tell the story by looking at the pictures public school. He flies through them because he is on an IEP since the beginning the... Will catch on that he would be a more difficult one to answer find us on Pinterest: you... Believes this is especially true for children who turned 5 just before they started school those. Neighborhood for its school Rating sandbox & Co., a digital learning company practice in evaluation. Is no denying that the decision is taken for the child & # x27 t. Experience, as well as sharing this important study my son is smarter than her.... Its students he was immature socially and to our knowledge he has been revised! Betwixt and between he is in kindergarten depends on many factors, not just intellectual ability 2.! Due to his maturity level emotionally developed as his or her peers grade retention the... On March 18th in our state just before they started school or who. Oldest ( at a private Christian school others will look at you Start. Seem immature for my son, i grew concerned with our sons placement next.. Consider is whether your child is as emotionally developed as his or her..

Montgomery County Texas Property Tax Exemptions, Keith Greene Obituary, Articles R